Historical Responsibility, Historical Perspective

Abstract

This article examines the problem of understanding historical responsibility in the context of historical perspective. The author questions what makes responsibility historical, in which ways responsibility can be written into a chronology and how the meaning of responsibility should be understood. Based on Agamben’s reconsideration of Pilate’s trial of Jesus, an analysis of the origins of contemporary dualism in understanding the responsibility of the metaphysical perspective of an unchanging semantic value and the variability of the requirements of contingent situations for the execution of an act is carried out. In addition, the article examines the relationship of responsibility for the past (primarily constituted through the prism of guilt and memory) and responsibility for the future as viewed in an instrumentalist vein and in the context of messianism. Historical responsibility can be conceptualised on the basis of an ontological approach to understanding responsibility (Heidegger, Levinas, Derrida, Nancy), according to which the connections of responsibility are not limited to imputations of obligations to recognise guilt, but rely on the fundamental basis of human activity. With this method of consideration, the historicity of responsibility does not lie in the localisation of certain events on time intervals, but rather is seen as the unfolding of the meaning of human deeds, thanks to which people, actions, intentions and ideas are organised into a single historical perspective. Historical relationships of responsibility are not limited by the time, space or social status of people, but are tied by the finitude of the existence of those whom they bind.

Author Biography

Daria Tomiltseva, Ural Federal University, Yekaterinburg, Russia

Daria Tomiltseva is Associate Professor of Social Philosophy of the Institute of Social and Political Sciences at Ural Federal University. Her principle research interests are forgiveness, reconciliation, peace, ethics, sociality, historical responsibility, moral responsibility.

References


  • Agamben, G. (2015). Pilate and Jesus. Stanford: Stanford University Press.

  • Agamben G. (2009). Theory of Signatures. In Agamben G. The Signature of all things: on method. NY: Zone books.

  • The Act of Civil Consent. (2016). Retrieved from http://blog.stepanivanovichkaragodin.org/?p=11119#more-11119

  • Arendt H. (2006). Eichmann in Jerusalem. London: Penguin books.

  • Brennan A., Lo Y.-S. (2016). Environmental Ethics. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (edited by E.N. Zalta). Retrieved from https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2016/entries/ethics-environmental/

  • Derrida J. (2005). On Forgiveness In Derrida J. On Cosmopolitism and Forgiveness. London and New York: Routledge.

  • Duncan P. J. S. (2000). Russian Messianism: Third Rome, Revolution, Communism and After. London: Routledge.

  • Dusenbury D. L. (in press). The Judgment of Pontius Pilate: a Critique of Giorgio Agamben. Journal of Law and Religion. Preprint version retrieved from https://www.academia.edu/13277730/The_Judgement_of_Pontius_Pilate_
    A_Critique_of_Giorgio_Agamben_
    Journal_of_Law_and_Religion_2017_

  • Erlich S.E. (2016). Global Memory of the Information Society: Ethics, Identity, Narrative. Historical Expertise, 3, 11-32.

  • Finkel E.V. (2011). In Search of Lost Genocides. Pro et Contra, May-August. Retrieved from http://carnegieendowment.org/files/ProetContra_52_123-143.pdf

  • Frank P., Nezhyba J., Heydenreich C. (2006). Taking Corporate Social Responsibility Seriously. Ekologický právní servis – Environmental Law Service, Brno.

  • Global Memory: a Culture of Historical Responsibility in the 21st century. (2016). Historical Expertise, 3, 7-10.

  • Guibernau M. (2008). National Identity versus Cosmopolitan Identity. In D. Held, H.L. Moore and K. Young (eds.). Cultural Politics in a Global Age, 148-156. Oxford: Oneworld.

  • Green M.J. (2002). Institutional Responsibility for Global Problems. Philosophical Problems, 30 (2), 79-95.

  • Jameson D. (2013). Climate Change, Consequentialism, and the Road Ahead. Chicago Journal of International Law, 13(2). Retrieved from http://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1375&context=cjil

  • Jimerson C.R. (2007). Archives for All: Professional Responsibility and Social Justice. The American Archivist, 70, 252-281.

  • Johnson G.F., Michaelis L., ed. (2013). Thinking Justice after Marion Young. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

  • Merkel W. (2008). Democracy through War? Democratization, 15 (3), 487-508.

  • Miller A. (2016). The Politics of Memory in Postcommunist Europe and its Impact on the European Culture of Memory. Polity, 1, 111-121.

  • Nancy J.-L. (1999). Responding for Existence. Studies in Practical Philosophy, 1 (1), 1-11. DOI: 10.5840/studpracphil1999112

  • Pakhlyuk K.A. (2016). Global Memory Culture: in Search of a Teleological Perspective. Historical Expertise, 3, 33-49.

  • Raffoul F. (2010). The Origins of Responsibility. Bloomington, Indianopolis: Indiana University Press.

  • Sarkar S. (2016). “Ecology”, The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (edited by Zalta E.N.). Retrieved from https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2016/entries/ecology/

  • “Nazvat’ imena palachey” [To Call the Names of Executioners] (2016). Retrieved from http://tv2.today/TV2Old/Nazvat-imena-palachey

  • Victory-70: the Reconstruction of the Anniversary (2015). Ed. Gennady Bordyugov. Moscow: Airo-XXI.

  • Yakovlev V. (2016). “Moy ded – Chekist i Ubiytsa” [My grandfather – Chekist and Murderer]. Retrieved from Facebook https://www.facebook.com/1206441856087060/photos/a.1214617398602839.1073741828.1206441856087060/1214765738588005/?type=1&theater

Published
2017-09-29
How to Cite
TOMILTSEVA, Daria. Historical Responsibility, Historical Perspective. Changing Societies & Personalities, [S.l.], v. 1, n. 2, p. 169-184, sep. 2017. ISSN 2587-8964. Available at: <https://changing-sp.com/ojs/index.php/csp/article/view/14>. Date accessed: 20 july 2018. doi: https://doi.org/10.15826/csp.2017.1.2.012.