The End of Utopias?

  • Leonid Fishman Institute for Philosophy and Law, Ural Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Yekaterinburg, Russia

Abstract

The present article discusses the legitimacy of the question: Are we really living in the era of "the end of utopias"? It is argued that a positive response to this question is possible only if, when considering utopias, their predominantly "left" content, left phraseology and the declaration of left anti-capitalist goals are placed at the forefront. However, if we approach utopias from the point of view of their objectively executable functions, their primary content is no longer utopian in the usual sense. A utopia is always a "function of the real" (Labica, 2004, p. 291). Contemporary utopian consciousness should be considered taking into account that: (a) utopias are inextricably linked with capitalism; (b) they serves its transformation (defining its "spirit" by its criticism) in transition from one stage to another; (c) they are an expression of the worldviews and aspirations of social groups (classes) rising at different stages of capitalism. Therefore, in order to find the place in the social structure in which modern utopias are born, it is necessary to locate the "rising class". The article defines the rising class as one that has, at least potentially, the greatest productivity. Its role in social production is increasing; around it are formed production, cultural and other relations, which become decisive according to the foreseeable historical perspective. The "creative class" is considered in terms of a contemporary rising class. Dazzled by its bright prospects, it is inclined to impose its utopia of the "creative economy" on the majority. The consequence of the rise of the "creative class" is a concomitant growth in the precarious social group of service workers and other social strata for whom the prospects of gaining entry into the ranks of the cognitariat are becoming increasingly unstable. Now that these strata are more likely to struggle for their existence, they find themselves trying to defend what has been lost without raising questions about the need to radically transform the social system. Variants of modern utopian consciousness are considered, proceeding from the outlined view of the socio-structural transformation of contemporary societies.

References


  • Alexander, J.C. (2002). Prochnye utopii i grazhdanskij remont [Stable Utopia and civil repair]. SOTSIS, 10, 3–11.

  • Aínsa F. (1997). Rekonstrukcija utopii [La reconstrucción de la utopia]. Retrieved from http://www.gumer.info/bibliotek_Buks/Polit/ainsa/01.php (accessed 4 Nov 2016).

  • Basova S. N. (2008). Marketing uslug [The marketing services]. Retrieved from http://www.studfiles.ru/preview/2896027/page:24/ (accessed 4 Nov 2016).

  • Bauman Z. (2005). Individualizirovannoe obshhestvo [The Individualized Society]. Moscow: Logos.

  • Beck U. (2007). Vlast’ i ee opponenty v jepohu globalizma [Power in the Global Age]. Moscow: Progress-Tradition.

  • Boltanski L., Chiapello E. (2011). Novyj dukh kapitalizma [Le nouvel esprit du capitalism]. Moscow: NLO.

  • Castel R. (2009). Metamorfozy social’nogo voprosa. Hronika naemnogo truda [Metamorphoses de la question sociale: Une chronique du salariat]. St. Petersburg: Aletheia.

  • Fishman L. G. (2016). Zakat «obshhestva truda»: sovremennaja ideologicheskaja konstelljacija [Decline of “work society”: current ideological constellation]. Politiya, 3, 116–129.

  • Fishman L. G. (2016a). “Transgumanizm – tupikovaja vetv’ Prosveshhenija?” [Transhumanism is a dead end of the Enlightenment?] In Horuzhiy S. S. et al. Posthuman and post-humanity: the Future of civilization or its end? (Round table). Bulletin of Moscow State Regional University, 3. 23–33. DOI: 10.18384/2224-0209-2016-3-757

  • Florida R. (2007). Kreativnyj klass: ljudi, kotorye menjajut budushhee [The Rise of the Creative Class. And How It’s Transforming Work]. Moscow: Klassika-XXI.

  • Florida R. (2016) Kreativnyj klass. Ljudi, kotorye sozdajut budushhee [Creative class: people who create the future]. Retrieved from http://www.litlib.net/bk/61386/read/2 (accessed 4 Nov 2016).

  • Ford M. (2016). Roboty nastupajut. Razvitie tehnologij i budushhee bez raboty [Rise of the Robots: Technology and the Threat of a Jobless Future]. Moscow: Alpina Non-Fiction.

  • Graeber D. (2014). O fenomene bespoleznyh rabot [On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs]. In Fragments of an Anarchist Anthropology. Moscow: Radical theory and practice. 150–156.

  • Graeber D. (2014a). Revoljucija naoborot [Revolution in reverse]. In Fragments of an Anarchist Anthropology. Moscow: Radical theory and practice. 124–150.

  • Johnson A. (2012). The New Communism: Resurrecting the Utopian Delusion. Retrieved from http://www.worldaffairsjournal.org/article/new-communism-resurrecting-utopian-delusion (accessed 4 Nov 2016).

  • Labica G. (2004). Marksizm mezhdu naukoj i utopiej [Le marxisme entre science et utopie]. (Suslov N. V., trans.) Nauchnyi Ezhegodnik Instituta filosofii i prava, Ural’skoe otdelenie Rossiiskoi akademii nauk, 5. 268–293.

  • Manche S. (2015). Capitalism and the Impossibility of Utopia: or the Incompatibility Problem. Retrieved from https://thenewutopians.wordpress.com/2015/05/26/capitalism-and-the-impossibility-of-utopia-or-the-incompatibility-problem/ (accessed 4 Nov 2016).

  • Mannheim K. (1991). Ideologija i utopija [Ideology and utopia]. In Utopiya i utopicheskoe myshlenie: antologiya zarubezhnoy literatury [Utopia and utopian thinking] (Comp. by V. A. Chalikova). Moscow: Progress. 113–170.

  • Marcuse H. (2004). Konets Utopii [The End of Utopia]. Logos, 6. 18–23.

  • Martianov V. S. (2016). Kreativnyj klass – kreativnyj gorod: real’naja perspektiva ili utopija dlja izbrannyh? [Creative Class Creative City: Real Perspective or Utopia for the Few?] Mirovaja ekonomika i mezhdunarodnye otnoshenija, 60 (10), 41–51. DOI: 10.20542/0131-2227-2016-60-10-41-51

  • Rosanvallon P. (2007). Utopicheskij kapitalizm. Istorija idei rynka [Le capitalisme utopique]. Moscow: NLO.

  • Žižek S. (2012). God nevozmozhnogo: iskusstvo mechtat’ opasno [The year of dreaming dangerously]. Moscow: Evropa.

Published
2017-12-18
How to Cite
FISHMAN, Leonid. The End of Utopias?. Changing Societies & Personalities, [S.l.], v. 1, n. 3, p. 259-270, dec. 2017. ISSN 2587-8964. Available at: <https://changing-sp.com/ojs/index.php/csp/article/view/18>. Date accessed: 20 july 2018. doi: https://doi.org/10.15826/csp.2017.1.3.018.
Section
Articles